The agenda for this meeting is available here.
Problem Review Board Members present (x=absent/excused):
Jim Mather x-Doug Sisterson
Raymond McCord Jimmy Voyles
Randy Peppler x-Richard Wagener
Robin Perez
I. Discussion of PIFs for assignment
P080702.1 NSA/SGP/TWP/SONDE - Occasional incorrect surface values of T/RH
Discussion:RID-509
Actions:
Assign To: Keck
- cc: Holdridge, Ritsche, Jones, REPO, DQO
P080702.2 SGP/SONDE/C1 - DigiCORA-III component failures
Discussion:
Actions:
Assign To:assign to Rusk to look for environmental causes (power,
cooling, ventilations)
- cc: Holdridge, Ritsche, Coulter, Voyles, Breedlove, Jones,
Ivey, Nitschke, Hartsock, Keck, McCord, DQO
P080707.1 SGP/TWR/C1 - Regular Missing Data
Discussion:
Actions:
Assign To:Rusk
- cc: Cook, Voyles, Breedlove, Hartsock, Eagan, Keck, McCord,DQO
II. CARs submitted for PIF closure
C080701.1 Submitted by Nicole Keck for
P050330.1 SGP/SONDE/C1 - Corrupted radiosonde data file
Discussion:Robin will request removal of the bad sonde cdf file.
Actions:accept CAR
C080702.1 Submitted by Jeffrey Zirzow for
P060717.1 NSA/AERI/C1/S01 - Temperature control is required in adjacent shelters
containing the AERI
Discussion:
Actions:accept CAR. add Denny Hackel to cc:list
C080708.1 Submitted by Victor Morris for
P070410.1 ALL/IRT - measurement bias at low sky temperatures
Discussion:
Actions:accept CAR
III. Attachments
A070410.1.5 Submitted by Victor Morris for
P070410.1 ALL/IRT - measurement bias at low sky temperatures
Discussion:
Actions:accept attachment
A080201.1.8 Submitted by Annette Koontz for
P080201.1 NSA/MWRP/C1 - Files contain NaN values
Discussion:
Actions:accept attachment
IV. DQRs
D051207.2 SGP/MFRSR/E3 - Missing data
Discussion:
Actions:accept modified DQR (added 3 new time periods)
- do not re-distribute
D080424.1 SGP/EBBR/E18 - Soil Heat Flow #4 Too Large; Sensible and Latent Heat Flux Sometimes Incorrect
Discussion:
Actions:hold DQR (DQPR #1949)
- DQPR reports SHF #4 was bad 20080413-20080506; SHF #4 replaced
20080506 but incorrect coefficient applied. Coefficient
corrected 20080617.
- at PRB request, Dave modified this DQRs end date and added
another for the 2nd period. Text for this DQR does not match
the problem described originally in the DQPR
- Robin called Dave; left message asking him to edit text
D080520.2 NSA/CSPHOT/C1 - Instrument out for repair, data missing
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1959)
- cc: Gregory, Wagener, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, DQO
D080526.1 SGP/ECOR/E10 - Instrument problem
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1961)
- cc: Cook, Hartsock, DQO
D080611.2 TWP/SMET/C3 - Lower Wind Direction Intermittently Wrong
Discussion:
Actions:hold DQR (DQPR #1970)
- DQPR and DQR have different end dates
- Robin called Mike; left message asking him to clarify date
D080612.1 NSA/METTWR/C1 - CMH required Calibration
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1971)
- cc: Ritsche, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, DQO
D080616.5 SGP/EBBR/E15 - Soil Heat Flow #4 Incorrect
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1978)
- cc: Cook, Hartsock, DQO
D080617.3 SGP/SIRS/E4 - tracker inoperative
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1981)
- cc: Gotseff, Stoffel, Hartsock, DQO
D080630.1 NSA/SKYRAD/C1 - tracker inoperative
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR (DQPR #1987)
- cc: Gotseff, Stoffel, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, DQO
D080701.2 SGP/MWR/B4 - Missing data
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- delete D001110.5, D001114.15, D001204.1, D030616.4,D051021.1,
D051122.1
- cc: Cadeddu, Hartsock, DQO
D080702.2 SGP/EBBR/E18 -
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- link to D080424.1 and DQPR #1949
- cc: Cook, Hartsock, DQO
D080703.1 SGP/MFRSR/E1 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Hartsock, REPO, DQO
D080703.2 SGP/MFRSR/E13 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Hartsock, REPO, DQO
D080703.3 SGP/MFRSR/C1 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Hartsock, REPO, DQO
D080703.4 TWP/MFRSR/C1 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Long, REPO, DQO
D080703.5 TWP/MFRSR/C2 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Long, REPO, DQO
D080703.6 TWP/MFRSR/C3 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Long, REPO, DQO
D080703.7 NSA/MFRSR/C1 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, REPO, DQO
D080703.8 NSA/MFRSR/C2 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, REPO, DQO
D080703.9 FKB/MFRSR/M1 - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Miller, Bartholomew, REPO, DQO
D080703.10 SGP/MFRSR/En - Incorrect alltime units
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- RID-510
- cc: Hodges, Hartsock, REPO, DQO
D080703.11 SGP/SMOS/E7 - Missing data
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Hartsock, DQO
D080703.12 SGP/SMOS/E7 - Missing data
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- delete D040715.2, D050131.8
- cc: Ritsche, Hartsock, DQO
D080707.2 TWP/SMET/C1 - ORG Precip Data Incorrect
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Long, DQO
D080710.2 NSA/MWRP/C1 - Instrument needs LN2 calibration--Reprocessing needed
Discussion:
Actions:accept open-ended DQR
- ask Maria for PIF to accompany open-ended DQR
- Robin to submit repo task to queue (RID #511)
- cc: Cadeddu, Verlinde, Bahrmann, Richardson, REPO, DQO
D080714.1 SGP/MWR/B5 - Computer problem-missing data
Discussion:
Actions:reject DQR
- Robin to submit single black DQR for SGP.B5 MWR
D080714.2 SGP/OKM/X1 - Overview of Automated Data Quality - March 2008
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- cc: Ma, Wagener
D080714.3 SGP/OKM/X1 - Overview of Automated Data Quality - April 2008
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- cc: Ma, Wagener
D080714.4 SGP/OKM/X1 - Overview of Automated Data Quality - May 2008
Discussion:
Actions:accept DQR
- cc: Ma, Wagener
D080714.5 SGP/MWR/C1 - Software/computer problem-Missing data
Discussion:
Actions:reject DQR
- Robin to add missing data period(s) to D080103.2
D080714.6 NSA/GVR/C1 - Computer failure--missing data
Discussion:
Actions:reject DQR
- Robin to add missing data period(s) to D070117.1
Review of Open-Ended DQRs:
Review of Warehouse DQRs:
Review of DQRs on Hold:
V. Overviews of Problems
Instruments - Jimmy Voyles
P050826.1 can be closed, procedures are in place for
salt-plating.
Lynn: please mark this PIF as closed.
ARM Operations - Doug Sisterson
Engineering - Jim Mather
Archive - Raymond McCord
Data Quality Office - Randy Peppler
1) One tardy "pending DQR" DQPR; DQO will submit the DQR for Vic
to close this DQPR
2) DQO will do daily statistics on QC metrics and file DQPRs
while the AMF is still in China and PIFs after the AMF is moved
when the actual data are available
3) Picking back up on the issue of AERI post-ingest QC data w/Turner
4) Registered displeasure that Rick got to go to Maine. Why can't
we all go to Maine?
Problem/Data Quality Reporting - Robin Perez
External Data Center - Rick Wagener
No call 7/22. Randy unavailable 7/29.