The agenda for this meeting is available here.
Problem Review Board Members present (x=absent/excused):
Ted Cress Robin Perez
xRic Cederwall Doug Sisterson
xJim Liljegren Jimmy Voyles
Raymond McCord Richard Wagener
Randy Peppler
I. Discussion of PIFs for assignment
P030618.1 SGP CR10(X) Loggers - Lithium Battery Test
Discussion: to be tracked in BCR-679
Actions:
Assign To: Robin Perez, also accept C030623.1
CC: David Cook, James Teske, Jeffrey Zirzow, James Liljegren,
Larry Jones, Bernard Zak, IT
II. CARs submitted for PIF closure
C030609.4 Submitted by Brian Ermold for
P021127.1 SGP - raw data have been corrupted by the data collection process
Discussion:
Actions: OK, see last week, did PRB-reviewed flag not get change?
C030616.1 Submitted by Annette Koontz for
P030115.1 TWP/SMET/C1/C2/C3 - Incorrect minimum for precip_mean
Discussion: ask Mike if DQR is appropriate
Actions: OK
C030619.1 Submitted by John Schmelzer for
P030604.1 NSA/NIMFR/C1 - Logger board produces erratic data
Discussion:
Actions: OK, ask Donna for DQR
ask Sig for low priority reprocessing task
III. Attachments
A020715.1.5 Submitted by Robin Perez for
P020715.1 NSA/SGP - rwp_ingest dumps core
Discussion:
Actions: OK, close Richard Coulter's assignment with Brian's CAR C030609.3
A020723.1.3 Submitted by Kevin Widener for
P020723.1 SGP/MMCR/C1 - SGP MMCR Reduction in Temporal Resolution
Discussion:
Actions: OK
A020923.1.3 Submitted by Kevin Widener for
P020923.1 TWP/MMCR/C2 - Solaris Computer Failed
Discussion:
Actions: OK, link to P030129.1
A021210.1.4 Submitted by Kevin Widener for
P021210.1 TWP/C1/C2 - Time Stamp on Data Systems
Discussion:
Actions: OK
A030129.1.3 Submitted by Kevin Widener for
P030129.1 TWP/MMCR/C2 - TWTA Down
Discussion:
Actions: OK
A030521.1.4 Submitted by Jason Christy for
P030521.1 TWP/QMEMWRCOL/C2 - More than 1 file per day
Discussion:
Actions: OK
IV. DQRs
D020815.5 NSA/NIMFR/C2 - Unstable detector temperature
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Donna Flynn, John Schmelzer, Johannes Verlinde, Karen
Sonntag, Andy Dean, Chad Shafer, Randy Peppler
D020815.6 NSA/GNDMFR/C2 - Unstable detector temperature
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Donna Flynn, John Schmelzer, Johannes Verlinde, Karen
Sonntag, Andy Dean, Chad Shafer, Randy Peppler
D020823.18 NSA/VCEIL/C1 - vceil25K Instrument maintenance
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Connor Flynn, Johannes Verlinde, Karen Sonntag, Andy Dean,
Chad Shafer, Randy Peppler
D030515.1 TWP/MFRSR/C1 - Instrument noise problem, Shadowband Misalignment
Discussion: Chad shouldn't have seen Development datastreams,
measurement descriptions also seem out of date
(2001-04-01 change).
Actions: remove following data streams:
DtwpmfrsrC1.a0
DtwpmfrsrC1.a1
DtwpmfrsrC1.b1
(these should be removed from picklist and from archive,
ask Betsy Horwedel to check existance of appropriate
end_allow_dqr date, ask Kathy Doty to verify operation
of DQR form)
- narrowband variable names incorrectly reported for .a1 and
.b1 (ask Kathy about how this can be prevented)
level data streams (variable names changed 4/1/01)
- cc: D.Flynn, Schmelzer, Mather, Long, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer,
Peppler
D030616.5 TWP/MMCR/C1 - Noise level shift
Discussion:
Actions: OK, correct typo ("resulting in missing")
CC: Widener, Mather, Long, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030617.1 TWP/SONDE/C1 - Broken temperature sensor
Discussion:
Actions: OK, add twpsondewnpnC1.a1 (dp, rh, tdry)
CC: Lesht, Mather, Long, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030617.3 TWP/SONDE/C2 -
Discussion:
Actions: OK, add twpsondewnpnC1.a1 (dp, rh, tdry),
change subject to:
TWP/SONDE/C2 - Broken temperature sensor
CC: Lesht, Mather, Long, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030618.5 SGP/SWATS/E18 - Planned data outage
Discussion:
Actions: OK, remove following defunct data streams:
DsgpswatsE18.00
DsgpswatsE18.a1
sgpswatsE18.01
(remove from picklist, also, ask Betsy Horwedel to update
metadata)
- open ended DQR w/o a PIF. Associated with BCRs 636 and
671. Can we link the DQR to BCR-671? Otherwise, should
have a PIF.
- cc: Bond, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.2 SGP/SMOS/E1 - E1 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES INCORRECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.3 SGP/SMOS/E1 - E1 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.4 SGP/SMOS/E1 - E1 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.5 SGP/SMOS/E5 - E5 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES OFF-SCALE
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.6 SGP/SMOS/E5 - E5 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.7 SGP/SMOS/E5 - E5 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.8 SGP/SMOS/E3 - E3 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES INCORRECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.9 SGP/SMOS/E3 - E3 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.10 SGP/SMOS/E3 - E3 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.11 SGP/SMOS/E6 - E6 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES OFF-SCALE
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.12 SGP/SMOS/E6 - E6 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.13 SGP/SMOS/E6 - E6 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.14 SGP/SMOS/E4 - E4 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES INCORRECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.15 SGP/SMOS/E4 - E4 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.16 SGP/SMOS/E4 - E4 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.17 SGP/SMOS/E9 - E9 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES OFF-SCALE
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.18 SGP/SMOS/E9 - E9 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.19 SGP/SMOS/E9 - E9 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.20 SGP/SMOS/E13 - E13 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES INCORRECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.21 SGP/SMOS/E13 - E13 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.22 SGP/SMOS/E13 - E13 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.23 SGP/SMOS/E24 - E24 SMOS 1-MINUTE DATA VALUES INCORRECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.24 SGP/SMOS/E24 - E24 SMOS 30-MINUTE DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.25 SGP/SMOS/E24 - E24 SMOS DAILY DATA VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.26 SGP/SMOS/E6 - E6 SMOS RH% VALUES ARTIFICIALLY LOW
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030620.27 SGP/SMOS/E6 - E6 SMOS 30-MINUTE AND DAILY RH% VALUES SUSPECT
Discussion:
Actions: OK
CC: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Randy Peppler
D030623.2 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.3 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.4 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.5 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.6 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.7 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.8 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.9 - accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.10- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.11- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.12- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.13- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.14- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.15- accept DQR
- text says 30-min data incorrect; ask Ritsche if color
should be red?
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
D030623.16- accept DQR
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
U030623.17- accept Green DQR
- change subject to:
SGP/SMOS - Data Quality Controlled
- cc: Ritsche, Sonntag, Dean, Shafer, Peppler
Review of Open-Ended DQRs:
Not reviewed.
Review of Warehouse DQRs:
Not reviewed.
Review of DQRs on Hold:
Not reviewed.
V. Overviews of Problems
Randy Peppler: moved DQ machine to PNNL
Rick Wagener: move PeopleDB to BNL
Robin Perez: DQRs with multiple colors for SIRS not possible. Need
summary DQR (transparent) with quality statistics, one
per month for each facility. Need separate DQR for
cases that need to be commented on, for reasonably severe
problems.
Need to be able to submit multiple DQRs for same DQPR.
Additional item for next week's agenda: Add discussion of Mike
Ritsche's need to submit separate DQRs for 30 and 1440
minute SMOS data, get briefed of results of any such
discussion at the IM-meeting from James Liljegren.
Next week: All here, except Randy Peppler maybe.